The "rent out your second car" pitch has been around since 2014. Every couple years some VC-backed startup shows up with a slicker app and promises. Most owners I've talked to found the reality either much better than advertised or much worse, and it comes down almost entirely to the vehicle they picked.
Let me show you what owners on RideshareRenter actually earn — and where the money quietly disappears.
These are real averages pulled from active listings. Gross before expenses.
| Vehicle | Weekly rate | Occupancy | Gross monthly | Net after expenses |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 Toyota Camry | $279 | 88% | $1,063 | $685 |
| 2020 Toyota Prius | $319 | 92% | $1,270 | $860 |
| 2018 Honda Accord | $269 | 85% | $990 | $625 |
| 2021 Tesla Model 3 SR+ | $389 | 87% | $1,465 | $1,010 |
| 2020 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid | $299 | 86% | $1,113 | $740 |
| 2019 Toyota Highlander (XL) | $399 | 79% | $1,365 | $815 |
| 2017 Chevy Cruze | $199 | 68% | $585 | $290 |
The cheap compact at $199/week looks like bad math, and it mostly is — low occupancy on older economy cars plus outsized maintenance costs. The Prius and Model 3 are the dominant performers because gig drivers specifically hunt them down for fuel/energy cost savings.
Owners who tell me they're "clearing $1,500 a month passive" on a Camry usually haven't done the subtraction yet. Real expense line per month: commercial rideshare insurance covered by RideshareRenter (worth ~$180/month if you bought it yourself); maintenance amortization at $140-180/month for a Camry doing 6,000 miles/month (oil changes every 3,500-5,000 miles, tires every 35,000-45,000 miles, brakes every 25,000-40,000); depreciation beyond personal-use baseline at $90-130/month in reduced eventual resale; cleaning between renters $0-60/month; minor repairs $30-50/month.
Highest real returns come from three categories. Hybrids under 5 years old: drivers save $60-100/week in fuel versus ICE, so they'll pay up. High occupancy, long bookings. Teslas Model 3 or Y SR trims: gig drivers love them for Uber Comfort and Green premiums — watch tire costs, rideshare Teslas eat tires in 22,000-30,000 miles. Minivans and 3-row SUVs for XL: less competition on supply, steady demand. The Sienna Hybrid is arguably the single best owner vehicle right now.
Worst returns: old economy cars (a 2017 Cruze at $199/week looks appealing until 32% of weeks go unbooked and every maintenance visit is $400); luxury trims under 3 years old (BMWs and Mercedes wear fast and cost a fortune to repair); trucks (gig drivers don't rent them for ridesourcing, niche delivery use only).
A car you rent out is generally a business asset. Income is taxable as rental business income on Schedule C or E. You can depreciate the vehicle using MACRS over 5 years — for a $25,000 car that's ~$5,000/year in early years. You can deduct platform fees, maintenance, insurance supplements, tires, and a portion of interest if financed. You pay self-employment tax (15.3% of net) if Schedule C. Converting a personal-use vehicle to business use has basis implications — talk to a CPA before you start.
A good rule of thumb: after depreciation and legitimate expenses, taxable income on a car earning $10,000/year gross often lands around $3,500-$5,000 in years 1-2. Not zero, but a lot less than the gross. I'm not a CPA. Actually talk to one.
You'll get scratches and dings — not catastrophic but persistent. Budget for the car to look 3 years older than its age after 18 months of rental use. You'll field messages at inconvenient times. You need to actually hand the car off — hands-free key lockboxes solve this. Your car will get pulled over occasionally; when the driver running it has an expired document, you're the registered owner getting the letter.
Minimum commitment for owners? No minimum. List when available, take it down when not.
Do I need a commercial license or LLC? Not for listing. LLC is worth considering once you're renting multiple vehicles.
What if a renter totals my car? Platform's commercial policy covers it. Actual cash value payout, which for a 5-year-old Camry in 2026 is roughly $14,500-17,000.
Can I still drive my own car sometimes? Yes, during unbooked weeks. Mixing personal and rental use has tax implications — keep a mileage log.
What if the renter gets a parking ticket? Citations follow the renter through most platforms. RideshareRenter passes tickets through based on rental date/time.
What vehicles get the fastest bookings? Prius, Camry Hybrid, Model 3, Sienna Hybrid — in that order. If you have one of those under 6 years old, it'll book within a week of listing.
The "passive income" label is marketing. It's low-effort income, not zero-effort. If you have a qualifying hybrid or EV you're not using daily, renting it out on RideshareRenter will realistically net $700-$1,100/month after honest expenses. That's enough to matter. It's not enough to retire on.
For owners: See what your vehicle would rent for in your market. List your car on RideshareRenter →
For drivers: Looking for a hybrid or EV rental that's actually covered for gig work? Browse available rentals →
Comments